SEC's Liquid Staking Guidance Draws Internal Criticism and Market Uncertainty

The Corporation Finance division of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has released a new statement on liquid staking. The latest statement has created a controversy within the commission as well as the crypto market about regulatory clarity. The guidance was released in an effort to clarify the SEC’s view about certain liquid staking activities that may not constitute securities.

However, the fact that liquid staking has been defined as “safe harbors” has left key players in the SEC and the industry uncertain about its implications.

SEC’s Liquid Staking Guidance Draws Criticism

Commissioner Caroline Crenshaw has publicly criticized the statement, warning that the vague and limited scope of the guidance may lead to further confusion and regulatory risk. Crenshaw said in a harshly worded criticism, "The Liquid Staking Statement should provide little comfort to entities engaged in liquid staking," stressing that the document only reflects the opinions of SEC staff and not the whole Commission.

She warned that the assumptions behind the statement could put people in the market at risk of systemic problems like those that caused past financial crises. Her disagreement shows that there is a growing split inside the SEC over the appropriate way to regulate digital assets.

On the other hand, SEC Chairman Paul S. Atkins has backed the Division's work, saying that guidance is a step forward in providing clarity, even if it is restricted.

The guidance has direct implications for Ethereum-based liquid staking protocols, which dominate the decentralized finance (DeFi) space. These systems allow users to stake assets while receiving liquid tokens in return, tokens that can be traded or used elsewhere in DeFi markets.

Important Reads: SEC Recognizes Certain USD Stablecoins as Cash Equivalents in Updated Accounting Guidance

Although the statement is important, many key liquid staking platforms and prominent Ethereum developers have yet to make a comment about it. This lack of reaction has increased the sense of uncertainty among stakeholders and the market.

The latest move adds to the SEC’s complex and often criticized approach to crypto oversight. The past decisions against staking services like centralized platforms have already shaped the industry, and now the focus on liquid staking has introduced new legally gray areas.

As the crypto industry awaits further clarification or legal challenges, many entities operating liquid staking protocols are expected to proceed cautiously, especially those outside the narrowly defined safe zones of the new guidance. For now, Ethereum remains at the heart of the debate, as the SEC’s evolving posture continues to impact its ecosystem and the broader DeFi sector.